09 Feb 2025

light mode

Proof of Reserves: crypto exchanges are trying to rebuild trust

Proof of Reserves: crypto exchanges are trying to rebuild trust

After the FTX collapse, the remaining players are trying to recover confidence with the help of Proof of Reserves (PoR).

On this page

Proof of Reserves is an audit method to ensure that a centralized platform holds enough funds in reserve to cover its operations and user balances. Such a check has long been passed by all banks that are required to report on reserves to secure deposits.

PoR gives the impression of transparency to clients and regulators, and it provides them with a sense of security and stability. PoR also guards against fraud by employees of the centralized exchange. The audit is based on cryptographic verification and reduces the risk of misappropriation of funds.

Checking the appropriate amount of reserves involves reviewing all the exchange's balance sheets and comparing them to the funds held in their addresses.

How does a Proof of Reserve audit work?

Proof of Reserves uses the principle of cryptographic proofs based on the Merkle Tree, a hash structure that allows to efficiently track data.

A third-party auditor takes anonymous snapshots of exchange balances and combines them into the Merkle tree to create a common cryptographic hash. It allows you to check the exact balance by checking an anonymous number of balances with verified ones.

The auditor then needs to obtain digital signatures that confirm that the exchange controls the addresses of wallets in the blockchain, where funds are held. If accounts associated with a digital signature have the same or bigger balances as the cryptographic hash data of clients, it verifies that the company is indeed safely holding customer funds. 

Criticism of PoR

However, you cannot rely only on Proof of Reserves to prove solvency. Furthermore, only experts who understand the nuances of the process can be convinced of the honesty and quality of the verification performed.

For instance, two auditors, Armanino and Prager Metis, audited the FTX exchange just before it filed for bankruptcy. However, they found no loopholes.

Binance's Proof of Reserves also raised red flags. The exchange published a report that verified reserves and the sufficiency of funds to cover customer deposits. Later, Mazars, a firm that conducted the audit, admitted that they made no representations regarding the provision of reserves.

This comes after Kraken co-founder Jesse Powell criticized Binance's Proof of Reserves report. He tweeted the following:

I'm sorry but no. This is not PoR. This is either ignorance or intentional misrepresentation. The merkle tree is just hand wavey bullshit without an auditor to make sure you didn't include accounts with negative balances. The statement of assets is pointless without liabilities.

Jesse Powell’s tweet

Jesse Powell’s tweet

As a result, the centralized platform can falsify the audit or carry it out improperly. Exchanges can manipulate data by hiding unwanted information. Therefore, Proof of Reserves is not a security guarantee without an independent third-party auditor and additional proof of solvency.

Disadvantages of Proof of Reserves

Proof of Reserves may not be a reliable indicator of a fund's safety for other reasons. The loans and debts of the corporation are not revealed in such an audit. Therefore, the exchange can use Proof of Reserves to hide problems under self-regulation and transparency.

Another disadvantage of the method is the inability to reveal and confirm the addresses of the company's reserves after the audit. The platform may borrow funds for reserves in order to give the appearance of solvency, without actually having the necessary funds.

PoR is a solution that is far from perfect, but, nevertheless, if used correctly and responsibly, it helps to confirm sufficient reserves or their inconsistency with the required minimum.

The content on The Coinomist is for informational purposes only and should not be interpreted as financial advice. While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, we do not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or reliability of any content. Neither we accept liability for any errors or omissions in the information provided or for any financial losses incurred as a result of relying on this information. Actions based on this content are at your own risk. Always do your own research and consult a professional. See our Terms, Privacy Policy, and Disclaimers for more details.

Articles by this author

Latest News

MORE
Winklevoss Twins Consider IPO for Gemini Exchange

Winklevoss Twins Consider IPO for Gemini Exchange

The Winklevoss twins, Cameron and Tyler, are reportedly considering an initial public offering (IPO) for their cryptocurrency exchange, Gemini. If successful, this move would place Gemini among the growing list of crypto companies entering public markets.

09 Feb 2025
Trump Jr. States That Crypto Is America’s Path to Global Dominance

Trump Jr. States That Crypto Is America’s Path to Global Dominance

The crypto community has taken notice of Donald Trump Jr.’s latest remarks. Speaking at the Ondo Finance Summit in New York, he asserted that cryptocurrencies will play a crucial role in maintaining America’s global economic leadership.

07 Feb 2025
Rep. Green Criticizes TRUMP Coin at Congress Hearing

Rep. Green Criticizes TRUMP Coin at Congress Hearing

On February 6, the U.S. House Financial Services Committee held a hearing entitled “Operation Choke Point 2.0: The Biden Administration’s Effort to Put Crypto in the Crosshairs.”

07 Feb 2025
NFL Rivals Expands Web3 Gaming With Super Bowl NFT Cards

NFL Rivals Expands Web3 Gaming With Super Bowl NFT Cards

NFL Rivals, the blockchain-powered football game from Mythical Games, is rolling out a special in-game event to celebrate the biggest football showdown of the year.

07 Feb 2025

Latest News Alt

MORE
Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Jan 27, 2025)

Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Jan 27, 2025)

An overview of BTC, ETH, XAUT, and S&P500 charts, and the current cryptocurrency market dynamics.

27 Jan 2025
Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Jan 13, 2025)

Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Jan 13, 2025)

An overview of BTC, ETH, XAUT, and S&P500 charts, and the current cryptocurrency market dynamics.

13 Jan 2025
Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Jan 6, 2025)

Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Jan 6, 2025)

An overview of BTC, ETH, XAUT, and S&P500 charts, along with the current cryptocurrency market dynamics.

06 Jan 2025

Might Be Interesting

MORE
How Blockchain Helps Combat Disinformation

How Blockchain Helps Combat Disinformation

Fake news has become a global issue, shaping public opinion, fueling social tensions, and even influencing political decisions. With the rise of social media, the spread of misinformation has accelerated, making it increasingly difficult to regulate. However, blockchain technology offers a promising solution in the fight against fake news.

07 Feb 2025
Trading Psychology: How to Avoid Falling Victim to Your Own Biases

Trading Psychology: How to Avoid Falling Victim to Your Own Biases

The most successful traders aren’t always the smartest. More often, those who excel are the ones who understand psychological traps, manage their emotions, and maintain rationality under pressure.

03 Feb 2025
Liquidity Pools — The Engine Driving DeFi

Liquidity Pools — The Engine Driving DeFi

Liquidity pools fuel DeFi by enabling instant token swaps, but what exactly are they? These crowdsourced reserves make decentralized trading possible—but they also come with risks. Here’s what you need to know before diving in.

31 Jan 2025
Bitcoin Name Service — Making Web3 Addresses Easier to Read

Bitcoin Name Service — Making Web3 Addresses Easier to Read

As the Bitcoin blockchain evolves, new opportunities are emerging for users to interact with DEX technologies. One of the major advancements is the Bitcoin Name Service (BNS)—a protocol that replaces complex web3 addresses with names that are easy for humans to understand.

29 Jan 2025
How to Withdraw Bitcoin from PayPal: A Step-by-Step Guide

How to Withdraw Bitcoin from PayPal: A Step-by-Step Guide

PayPal is one of the most popular online payment platforms. In 2022, it introduced features that allow users to transact with cryptocurrencies, including Bitcoin (BTC). However, withdrawing crypto from PayPal is not as straightforward as transferring fiat funds. This guide will walk you through the process of withdrawing Bitcoin from PayPal.

29 Jan 2025
Crypto Wallet Backups: Are You Truly Ready for Self-Custody?

Crypto Wallet Backups: Are You Truly Ready for Self-Custody?

Being your own bank is one of the great perks of crypto. It’s perfect for those who want extra security or believe in decentralization. But self-custody isn’t exactly a walk in the park – you’ve got to master the art of backups because you’re the only one responsible for your assets.

28 Jan 2025

Opinions

Super Bowl Bets Under Fire: CFTC Probes Kalshi and Crypto.com

Super Bowl Bets Under Fire: CFTC Probes Kalshi and Crypto.com

The Super Bowl, the largest sporting event in the US, has more to it than just the competition. The exciting show and, of course, commercials and bets are a big part of it, too. The winner will become known as early as tomorrow. Not everything always goes smoothly, though.

08 Feb 2025
Arthur Hayes — Is Trump’s Crypto Policy Setting a Trap?

Arthur Hayes — Is Trump’s Crypto Policy Setting a Trap?

Arthur Hayes, in The Genie, argues that Trump’s crypto agenda might not be what it seems. Could regulatory changes lead to unexpected consequences? Read our full breakdown.

07 Feb 2025
MORE

Interviews

“Satoshi is CIA”: Swedish crypto bro opens up about his Bitcoin journey

“Satoshi is CIA”: Swedish crypto bro opens up about his Bitcoin journey

The first crypto craze took place almost a decade ago. Overnight, many people found out about Bitcoin and its underlying technology, blockchain.

31 Jan 2025
Dmytro Gordon and Volodymyr Nosov: A Sensational Interview

Dmytro Gordon and Volodymyr Nosov: A Sensational Interview

Volodymyr Nosov, CEO of Europe’s largest crypto exchange WhiteBIT, sat down with Dmytro Gordon, one of Ukraine’s most prominent journalists. The interview touched on Bitcoin, crypto, WhiteBIT, cars, keys to success, and business vision.

18 Dec 2024
MORE