18 Feb 2025

light mode

ECB: Bitcoin should not be legalized

ECB: Bitcoin should not be legalized

Amid the sudden collapse of one of the crypto market leaders, the ECB published a rather provocative blog post. Director general of market infrastructure and payments Ulrich Bindseil and advisor Jürgen Schaaf shared their predictions for the future of Bitcoin and t

On this page

“Bitcoin's Last Stand” is the blog's title that speaks volumes about the authors’ attitude towards the legendary cryptocurrency. It would seem that the hint is clear. But let's focus on the reasons behind Bindseil and Schaaf's skeptical claims.

The European Central Bank is convinced that after numerous ups and downs in Bitcoin's price, the long-awaited stabilization at ±$20,000 is not a breather on the way to new heights, but an “artificially induced last gasp.” Why don't bankers believe in Bitcoin's relevance and predict its imminent disappearance?

Bitcoin is not a means of payment

Though originally positioned as a decentralized global digital currency, Bitcoin has some shortcomings that prevent it from becoming a means of regular payments.

Real Bitcoin transactions are cumbersome, slow and expensive. Bitcoin has never been used to any significant extent for legal real-world transactions.

Bitcoin is not a good investment

Investing in Bitcoin was supposed to take cryptocurrency to a whole new level. However, bankers believe that it is absolutely not suitable as an investment. 

With an investment strategy, investors generate money, dividends, or direct profits from the use of various assets. The situation with Bitcoin is somewhat different: the ECB says that its market value is based purely on speculation. At the same time, the big Bitcoin investors, including many venture capital funds, constantly keep the euphoria going.

Speculative bubbles rely on new money flowing in. Bitcoin has also repeatedly benefited from waves of new investors.

Bitcoin is not “just another asset class”

Legislation that is being developed in different countries to regulate cryptocurrencies is slow to ratify, and even slower to implement. Another complicating factor is that the speed of decision-making and understanding of the crypto industry varies considerably in different jurisdictions. For example, while the EU has already developed clear rules for the crypto market (MiCA), U.S. authorities are still unable to agree on this issue.

The risks inherent in digital currencies require effective regulation and supervision. The number of crypto lobbyists in the U.S. has almost tripled between 2018 and 2021. They promote Bitcoin and seek to shape it as a traditional asset class. As a result, cryptocurrency is coming to retail investors as a promising investment. However, this should not be the case.

The supposed sanction of regulation has also tempted the conventional financial industry to make it easier for customers to access bitcoin. This concerns asset managers and payment service providers as well as insurers and banks. The entry of financial institutions suggests to small investors that investments in Bitcoin are sound.

Bitcoin is an inefficient system

Bindseil and Schaaf claim unprecedented pollution associated with the Bitcoin system. According to ECB officials, bitcoin mining consumes as much energy as the entire country of Austria, and the amount of e-wastes is comparable to that of the Netherlands.

This inefficiency of the system is not a flaw but a feature. It is one of the peculiarities to guarantee the integrity of the completely decentralised system.

Bitcoin bears a reputational risk for banks

The blog's authors are not dragging their feet: Bitcoin should not be legitimized. Banks shall be aware of the consequences of promoting crypto investments, because retail investors will sooner or later lose their money.

The negative impact on customer relations and the reputational damage to the entire industry could be enormous once Bitcoin investors will have made further losses.

The content on The Coinomist is for informational purposes only and should not be interpreted as financial advice. While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, we do not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or reliability of any content. Neither we accept liability for any errors or omissions in the information provided or for any financial losses incurred as a result of relying on this information. Actions based on this content are at your own risk. Always do your own research and consult a professional. See our Terms, Privacy Policy, and Disclaimers for more details.

Articles by this author
Lawmaker Attacks Trump’s Meme Coin, Musk’s DOGE

Lawmaker Attacks Trump’s Meme Coin, Musk’s DOGE

Democratic Congresswoman Ayanna Pressley has criticized the DOGE agency and Trump’s meme coin, arguing they represent a dangerous shift in financial oversight.

Anton Kryshtal
LIBRA Meme Coin Mystery—Is There a MELANIA Connection?

LIBRA Meme Coin Mystery—Is There a MELANIA Connection?

LIBRA’s sudden launch has left the crypto world divided. Was it just another meme coin stunt, or is there a real connection to Javier Milei? And what’s this about MELANIA? The plot thickens.

The Coinomist
Scammers Tricked Investors with a Fake Saudi Meme Coin

Scammers Tricked Investors with a Fake Saudi Meme Coin

Scammers impersonating Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman on X claimed to launch an “official” KSA meme coin. Spoiler alert: It was a total scam.

Anton Kryshtal
Italy Moves to Rein In Crypto as EU, U.S. Rules Diverge

Italy Moves to Rein In Crypto as EU, U.S. Rules Diverge

The Bank of Italy, together with the Italian securities regulator Consob, met with industry leaders to discuss the evolving rules for digital assets.

Anton Kryshtal
Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Feb 10, 2025)

Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Feb 10, 2025)

An overview of BTC, ETH, XAUT, and S&P500 charts, and the current cryptocurrency market dynamics.

Artem Khomenko
Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Feb 3, 2025)

Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Feb 3, 2025)

An overview of BTC, ETH, XAUT, and S&P500 charts, and the current cryptocurrency market dynamics.

Artem Khomenko
Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Jan 27, 2025)

Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Jan 27, 2025)

An overview of BTC, ETH, XAUT, and S&P500 charts, and the current cryptocurrency market dynamics.

Artem Khomenko
How to Bump a Transaction in the Bitcoin Network

How to Bump a Transaction in the Bitcoin Network

Sometimes, Bitcoin transactions can get “stuck,” especially if a low fee was set. In such cases, you might wonder: Why is my Bitcoin transaction stuck?

bitOn
Inside Cryptocurrency Farms: How Digital Coins Are Mined

Inside Cryptocurrency Farms: How Digital Coins Are Mined

Cryptocurrency farms and mining have evolved significantly since Bitcoin launched in 2009. To understand their growth, it helps to look at the broader history of resource extraction.

The Coinomist
From Bulls to Ballers — Why Celebrities Are Flocking to Crypto

From Bulls to Ballers — Why Celebrities Are Flocking to Crypto

Trump’s meme coin isn’t an outlier—it’s part of a broader trend. Back in 2021, celebrities were minting NFTs, and by 2024, they had moved on to personal token launches. The connection between fame and crypto has been growing for years, even if many failed to see it.

Vlad Vovk
Which Macroeconomic Factors Make Crypto Rise or Fall? 

Which Macroeconomic Factors Make Crypto Rise or Fall? 

It happens when you check the market and crypto prices are up or down for no obvious reason. Then you do some research and find out that there are actually reasons outside the crypto space.

Anahit Avetisyan
How Blockchain Helps Combat Disinformation

How Blockchain Helps Combat Disinformation

Fake news has become a global issue, shaping public opinion, fueling social tensions, and even influencing political decisions. With the rise of social media, the spread of misinformation has accelerated, making it increasingly difficult to regulate. However, blockchain technology offers a promising solution in the fight against fake news.

Daryna Nesterenko
Trading Psychology: How to Avoid Falling Victim to Your Own Biases

Trading Psychology: How to Avoid Falling Victim to Your Own Biases

The most successful traders aren’t always the smartest. More often, those who excel are the ones who understand psychological traps, manage their emotions, and maintain rationality under pressure.

Vlad Vovk
The Bitcoin Kid’s 2011 Prediction – How Right Was He? 

The Bitcoin Kid’s 2011 Prediction – How Right Was He? 

In May 2011, an unusual video surfaced on YouTube. A 12-year-old boy explained Bitcoin – how it works and what its future might hold.

Anahit Avetisyan
SBF’s Prosecutor Quits – What It Means for Crypto Crime

SBF’s Prosecutor Quits – What It Means for Crypto Crime

Danielle Sassoon, Acting U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York, has resigned, making headlines this week. And you’ve definitely heard of one of her biggest “client” names.

Anahit Avetisyan
MORE
«Mass Adoption Isn’t About Tech – It’s About Perception». Bitmedia Founder Matvii Diadkov – About RWA, Web3, And Marketing

«Mass Adoption Isn’t About Tech – It’s About Perception». Bitmedia Founder Matvii Diadkov – About RWA, Web3, And Marketing

Matvii Diadkov, founder of Bitmedia, shared with us in an exclusive interview his expert insights on Web3 adoption, impact of GameFi and community-centering tendencies in the market.

The Coinomist
“Satoshi is CIA”: Swedish crypto bro opens up about his Bitcoin journey

“Satoshi is CIA”: Swedish crypto bro opens up about his Bitcoin journey

The first crypto craze took place almost a decade ago. Overnight, many people found out about Bitcoin and its underlying technology, blockchain.

Lesia Dubenko
MORE